Importance of straps- newbie question

[Barb T]

The only kilts that actually _need_ a third strap are dancers' kilts. Highland dancers do not wear kilt pins, and the second apron-edge strap helps keep the kilt edge from flapping around.

I, too, try to talk people out of a third strap for all the reasons stated above.

[Standard]

Three is also my personal preference, but I do beleive that two would suffice nicely if that is how your kilt was made. I don't think that there is anything incorrect in the form of either number.

[Ryan Ross]

I notice that the third strap really does tend to pull the lines of the tartan out of skew. You can actually see it in many pictures on this very board, but I think that only happens with kilts that are worn fairly frequently.

[Scotus]

I'm with McClef on this one. Keeping the kilt up is the main thing. While the extra strap is not needed, both my traditional kilts have the extra strap and I would most likely ask for the extra strap if I ordered another kilt. Why? Because I think the extra strap is very cool!

[emolas]

As I see it, a third strap on a kilt is like a third nipple on a person.

That would also be a matter of preference


I prefer the symmetrical look of only two straps (and nipples...).

[Phil]

The tailor who made my kilt told me that an individually fitted kilt only needs 1 strap each side. The reason for the extra strap, he said, was down to the rental market so that a variety of body shapes could be accommodated by adjusting the third strap. Another "one size fits all" solution by the kilt-hirers just like the white hose. No doubt "off the peg" kilts will also have three straps for the same reason.

[Spc. Scott]

My SWK has three straps and I don't mind it at all. Like was said before, as long it stays up, that's the main thing.

[Ryan Ross]

That would also be a matter of preference


I prefer the symmetrical look of only two straps (and nipples...).

Nicely played.

...and agreed.

[Galb]

It all depends on your preference because that third strap really is useless. It is there for looks. If you like the look, then get it. If not, then skip it. I have two kilts, one has the three straps, the other only has two. It honestly doesn't matter to me one way or another, as long as there are straps and no velcro, I'm happy.

[Freedomlover]

I detest the third strap... As I see it, a third strap on a kilt is like a third nipple on a person.

That's a great way to put it. I agree completely.