The general opinion of Jacobite Shirts?

**michaelbeeman** · 22nd June 08, 11:36 AM

I picked one up last year to use in a photo shoot for a friend. The shoot didn't happen and I've never worn the shirt. Not really my style.

**McClef** · 22nd June 08, 11:37 AM

I like them - they are slightly more dressy than casual but slightly less dressy than, well, dressy.

I only have a green one at present, must expand my collection!

**12stones** · 22nd June 08, 12:02 PM

I'm not too fond of them as I find them costume'y' as well, but wear what you like. I'd agree with matching the shirt and the hose though. Can't wait to see that tank though.

**Jack Daw** · 22nd June 08, 01:48 PM

I don't care for them, but if you like the jacobite shirt that is all that matters. But, if you are going for an authentic historical look, this shirt is not accurate.

**keepoffgrass** · 22nd June 08, 02:35 PM

I have a couple Jacobite shirts, one in black one in dark green. They're comfortable, light weight, and I personally think they're nice looking with a kilt, even if they are a little bit costumey. My girlfriend however, absolutely loves them, and asks that I wear them more often. So, I guess what ever makes her happy lol

**Mael Coluim** · 22nd June 08, 03:56 PM

You might want to consider a Heritage Shirt from Empire Canvas Works.
Check Panache's reveiw here.
You could dye it the color you want.
I have one on the way.

**DWFII** · 22nd June 08, 04:03 PM

I think that from what I have heard the biggest objection to the "jacobite" shirt is that it is not historically authentic...with the cheesy lacing at the throat being the biggest hang-up. For something along the same lines but far more authentic try this shirt:

http://tinyurl.com/552s6u

They even have patterns if you want a particular to match your kilt.

**TheKiltedWonder** · 22nd June 08, 04:11 PM

I agree with may of those who find the Jacobtie shirt too similar to a costume. That said I do own one and if I were still in shape (read: if I still had the necessary muscles to fill it out) I might feel differently about it. Then again, it would probably still look rather like a costume.

**Woodsheal** · 22nd June 08, 04:17 PM

I hate the so-called "jacobite" shirts. They look like 1930's Hollywood pirate shirts! If you want an authentic 18th century shirt with proper long (knee-length) tails, check these out:
http://www.trailhd.com/shirts.html

**James MacMillan** · 22nd June 08, 04:35 PM

I've looked at them a few times, but like others have said, it's just not for me. Those shirts would be great for going to a ren-fair I guess, but they don't seem like a standard day-to-day wearable shirt. I guess my ideas, when it comes to shirts are pretty boring and common - but they are not for me.