The general opinion of Jacobite Shirts?

[TheKiltedWonder]

I agree with may of those who find the Jacobtie shirt too similar to a costume. That said I do own one and if I were still in shape (read: if I still had the necessary muscles to fill it out) I might feel differently about it. Then again, it would probably still look rather like a costume.

[Woodsheal]

I hate the so-called "jacobite" shirts. They look like 1930's Hollywood pirate shirts! If you want an authentic 18th century shirt with proper long (knee-length) tails, check these out:
http://www.trailhd.com/shirts.html

[James MacMillan]

I've looked at them a few times, but like others have said, it's just not for me. Those shirts would be great for going to a ren-fair I guess, but they don't seem like a standard day-to-day wearable shirt. I guess my ideas, when it comes to shirts are pretty boring and common - but they are not for me.

[Kilted in Maine]

As in the words of Jerry Sienfeld "But I don't want to be a prirate!"

Personally I don't like them.

But to each his own, if you like it and it is comfortable - Wear it!

[CelticRanger66]

I think the Jacobite shirt is ok but just not for me.

[Alaskan Kilted Guy]

Theay aren't my bag either. But I am a firm believer that people should do what they want to and like to. If you like it wear it brother!! Some folks can pull it off.

[Birddog]

Hmmm, looking around, I noticed that the Lewis Hose that I admire so much do not come in a linen color. So, is it acceptable that the hose do not match the shirt(complementing the kilt), but the flashes or garter ties do? I know typically that the flashes should match the kilt. Thinking that a Navy shirt in a typical cut and navy hose better idea.

[Riverkilt]

I made the mistake of buying a few made from synthetic fibers and they are HOT HOT HOT...I do like the cotton ones for special occasions. My daughter sent me one with a plunging neckline and ruffles that shows off my chest tattoo nicely that is perfect for a romantic dance evening with my lady. Other than the synthetic ones I find the looseness much cooler on hot days/evenings.



And the looseness helps hide some of the fat on the olde guy.

Ron

[kevinkinney]

Howdy all,

I'm gonna sound like a dweeb here...

In our buggy neighborhood, we draw on the style and substance of historical clothing for one good reason- it performed pretty well as a way to keep humans alive and comfortable. We began to make our Heritage Shirt in response to a groups of locals who asked for them as outerwear.

While our big billowy shirt has appeal for people with a renfaire/reenactment bend, I've actually only worn mine 3 times with a Kilt, and a great kilt at that. Is it perfectly appropriate? I doubt it. Is it historically correct? Heck no. Stainless Steel and snap fasteners weren't developed until the 19th century. Does it work? Yup- few bugs, less UV, really freeeking breathable. Do I dig great kilts? Yup- my next purchase of tartan will be dedicated to one for formals with a full doublet.

I'm partial to earth tone button down oxfords with my other kilts, not piracy.

I use my Heritage Shirt because I hate bugs, and my skin has spent too much time in the sun at altitude. When I feel saucy, I thrown on a pair of battered pants, moccasins, and wrap a Modern Douglas Tartan wool sash around my waist. That seems to clear people away on the sidewalks.

Cheers,

Kevin

[Spc. Scott]

I'm with the "if you like it wear it" crowd.
I used to have a nice black one a few years ago. Many moves later I have no idea where it is now.

Perhaps I need to go shopping.