Christopher Columbus was Scottish

[Bugbear]

Yep; don't know if it influenced our constatution; was around before our constatution, so may have been the first one in North America.

I don't have the resources to find the answers, but it is interesting.

[eiry]

Yep; don't know if it influenced our constatution; was around before our constatution, so may have been the first one in North America.

I don't have the resources to find the answers, but it is interesting.

This article makes me cringe with embarressment, I am ashamed that a lot of scots make preposterous claims on people and their achievments to basque in their glory, if its one thing we scots are good at it is basterdizing our culture.

Saying Christopher colombus was scottish is simply absurd and iridiculous no matter if he had a scots ancestor or two in his past (which I very much doubt).

[Bugbear]

I'm just a little country boy, alone out here in the desert, so I don't know anything about these big words.

However, I have seen several myths, that were tought to me as historical fact, torn apart and exposed as myth. I also know that events of the past are now being looked at again in new ways, with new tools, and in ways that would have been over looked or written off not too long ago.

So, the history books are never really closed.

[Bigkahuna]

I believe there are also stories of a Welsh prince who traveled around America way before Columbus and ended up living with the Mandans out on the Great Plains.

[macwilkin]

I believe there are also stories of a Welsh prince who traveled around America way before Columbus and ended up living with the Mandans out on the Great Plains.

That would be the legend of Madoc:

http://www.biographi.ca/009004-119.0...8k3fvrqj2njff6

T.

[Riverkilt]

Whoa!!

Is that rumor I started TRUE??

Makes me feel a bit better having been born on the old pre-government Columbus Day.

(kinda cute - my alcoholic little sister calls me to wish me a happy birthday on whichever day the government declares Columbus Day that year).

And a cute story some haven't heard. I'm in full turn out after the Flagstaff Highland Games. Got caught in a speed trap crossing the Navajo Nation on my way to Hopiland.

Navajo cop writes the ticket (you can NOT talk your way out of them) and after he's done he asks me why I'm dressed like I am.

Told him I just came from the Highland Games. He asks, "Who won?" He had no clue but got it when I told him the Highland Games were like a Scottish Pow - Wow.

I know many people were here before me, but this land will always be special to me since somewhere on the South bank of the Alabama River near an old Army Air Corps hospital lies a piece of my flesh. The victim of my first, and so far only, amputation.

My flesh is now part of the dust of this land.

Ron

[Bigkahuna]

Whoa!!

Is that rumor I started TRUE??

Makes me feel a bit better having been born on the old pre-government Columbus Day.

(kinda cute - my alcoholic little sister calls me to wish me a happy birthday on whichever day the government declares Columbus Day that year).

And a cute story some haven't heard. I'm in full turn out after the Flagstaff Highland Games. Got caught in a speed trap crossing the Navajo Nation on my way to Hopiland.

Navajo cop writes the ticket (you can NOT talk your way out of them) and after he's done he asks me why I'm dressed like I am.

Told him I just came from the Highland Games. He asks, "Who won?" He had no clue but got it when I told him the Highland Games were like a Scottish Pow - Wow.

I know many people were here before me, but this land will always be special to me since somewhere on the South bank of the Alabama River near an old Army Air Corps hospital lies a piece of my flesh. The victim of my first, and so far only, amputation.

My flesh is now part of the dust of this land.

Ron

Hope it wasn't something important!

[mbhandy]

I did not know that Columbus was Scotish???
As were the first visitors to North or South America were Aliens? ( If they were Green, where they Irish.)
I guess you learn something new every day. Myth or truth.

MrBill

[mexpiper]

WOW,... what a conversation...
what is the definition of "Discovered" a.To be the first, or the first of one's group or kind, to find, learn of, or observe.

Since I grew up in Seneca (Iroquois) territory and had many friends who are Haudenosaunee. We learned about the Confederation, in 7th grade as NY history was the whole year.

I did some basic research.... some of it is very controversial... but than again we have to remember that the Victors write the History books! (;} )

The Iroquois Confederacy (Haudenosaunee, also known as the League of Peace and Power) is a group of First Nations/Native Americans. Based in what is now upstate New York at the time of the arrival of the Europeans, they now occupy territory in Ontario, Quebec and New York.
History
The spiritual union of the nations began before European contact, replete with a Constitution recorded with special beads called wampum that served the same purpose as money in other cultures. Most Western anthropologists speculate that this Constitution was created sometime between the middle 1400s and early 1600s, but other scholars who account for Iroquois oral tradition argue that the event took place as early as 1100, with many arguing for August 31, 1142 based on a coinciding solar eclipse. Some Westerners have also suggested that this Constitution was written with European help, although most dismiss this notion as blatant racism.
The two prophets, Hiawatha and "The Great Peacemaker", brought a message of peace to related squabbling tribes.
……Haudenosaunee means "People Building a Long House." The term is said to have been introduced by The Great Peacemaker at the time of the formation of the Confederacy. It implies that the Nations of the confederacy should live together as families in the same longhouse.
The Iroquois nations' political union and democratic government has been credited as one of the influences on the United States Constitution.
http://www.crystalinks.com/iroquois.html

""In 2004 the U.S. Government acknowledged the influence of the Iroquois Constitution on the U.S. Framers.[14] The Smithsonian Institution also noted the similarities between the two documents, as well as the differences. One significant difference noted was the inclusion of women in the Iroquois Constitution, one group among many that the framers of the U.S. Constitution did not include.""

""Although their influence is hotly debated, it is a historical fact that several founding fathers had direct contact with the Iroquois, and prominent figures such as Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin were closely involved with the Iroquois, their stronger and larger native neighbor. Whether this was purely politics for protection or true admiration, perhaps can never be fully determined. ""

Check out the following references:
"The Six Nations: Oldest Living Participatory Democracy on Earth". Ratical.com. Retrieved on 2007-10-27.
 ^ Armstrong, Virginia Irving [1971]. I Have Spoken: American History Through the Voices of the Indians. Pocket Books, 14. SBN 671-78555-9.*
 ^ "Did the Founding Fathers Really Get Many of Their Ideas of Liberty from the Iroquois?". George Mason University. Retrieved on 2007-10-27.
 ^ Iroquois Confederacy and the Influence Thesis
 ^ "Iroquois Constitution Influenced That of U.S., Historians Say". U.S. Department of State. Retrieved on 2007-10-27."


I also have to check out more on Ben Franklin, as he had published many says and speeches of the Iroquois leader James Bryant and others.

[Bryan]

Some Westerners have also suggested that this Constitution was written with European help, although most dismiss this notion as blatant racism.

I'm sure you are quoting this, and the following comment is more of a general statement and is in no way directed at you, but I fail to see how the possibility, however remotely, of European help/influence could be considered "blatant racism."