Sorry to hear about your experience, as well. I've bought heavy weight kilting cloth from this vendor a few times in the past, and the selvedge has always been a very good, true kilting selvedge; and the fabric quality has always been very good to excellent.

I understand that this vendor is selling lengths of cloth left over from other mills closing, and so perhaps there may be some variation in the quality of the cloth. But my experience thus far has been positive.