backwoods,

I am a big fan of USA Kilts having three of their semi-traditional PV kilts and one of their 5 yard wool kilts. The casual package is a good value, but I would ask you what kind of kilted look appeals to you? If all you wish is a casual look then go for the package. However if you would like to be able to dress up your kilt then I would suggest saving up for the semi-traditional model.

The straps aren't really a factor (save for the look) on whether or not a kilt is formal looking or not (on handsewn wool two strap kilts you don't see the straps). However the USA casual kilt is worn lower on the hips than their semi-traditional model (which fits like a traditional kilt). This look is fine for a casual kilt but it isn't the way a traditional kilt looks. Also I believe the belt offered in the casual package is a standard 1.5 inch belt. While this is fine with a casual kilt outfit it is going to look wrong with a dressier one (where 2 1/2 belts are the standard).

It has been mentioned already that it is easier to dress down a more formal kilt than dress up a casual one. If you see yourself wanting to be able to dress up this first kilt in the future and fit into a more formal highland event with other kilt wearers it is worth it to go for the semi traditional kilt.

To give you an idea of what you can do with a USA semi-traditional kilt here are a few pictures of my Galbraith tartan one.















Though I have not done so, I wouldn't hesitate to wear it with my Prince Charlie Coatee.

By the by, as part of the Casual Kilt Package, Rocky offers two different Buzz Kidder Sporrans (the middle two). Even if you don't go for the package these are perhaps the very best choice for a black casual sporran. They are extremely well made, big, and of thick soft leather. Going with a cheaper option will not serve you in the long run like one of these.

Hope this was of some help.

Cheers

Jamie