Quote Originally Posted by Woodsheal View Post
Box- and Kingussie-pleated kilts are latter-day revivals of historic forms contemporaneous with the belted-plaid. Leaving aside the "comfort factor", to accept the first two forms as acceptable with "modern" attire, and to reject the latter (as another possible "revival"), is an entirely inconsistent argument - which argument then falls flat on its face.
I find it inconsistent too, which really seems to leave those against the idea with pretty much only, "But even though there was an overlap of perhaps anywhere up to a century where the great kilt and small kilt were both being worn, we kept wearing some form of small kilt up to the present and we don't wear the great kilt any more and therefore the great kilt with modern accoutrements looks weird and inappropriate and we don't like it".

Which also seems to me to be a perfectly valid contemporary Scottish cultural perspective.