Honestly? I wouldn't go for it at all.

Here's why:

1) it's not practical. Historically the kilt has evolved as the need has arisen. Truthfully, a highlander of yore would probaby prefer a modern coat to his woolen wrap.

2) Taking care of business in the woods would be difficult. I wouldn't want to soil my nice tartan. Try squatting in the woods after shelling out the dough for nice tartan and tell me you won't be nervous.

3) Hazardous. Risk of snagging on twigs and branches or being singed at a campfire...after spending a pretty penny on tartan? Not, I, sir.

4) Cleaning. After a romp in the hinterland your nice tartan will get dirty. Very dirty. Mud, muck, dirt, grime, and perspiration will take it's toll and necessitate frequent dry cleaning. Expensive over time.

5) Uncomfortable. The first hour or so will be fine but after a while you will start to feel the drag of the extra weight and begin fatiguing. Even the Highlanders discarded the great kilt after its brief period of use in favour of the small kilt. Practicality has always been the order of the day with regard to the Scots and their kilting.

6) Belted plaids are a bit costumey...but great for reenactments. The modern kilt is a functional garment suited for today don't be the "Braveheart" wannabe running around in the woods. Too many guys already do that to the disservice of kilties everywhere.

Just my tuppence. I mean no disrespect or insult but those are my honest thoughts.