I will wait. The kilt has a slightly different appearance than the other 2.

I am not sure that I am worried about the length. Scotweb/clan.com sizing has been pretty close to what I needed.

24" or 23.5" length is definitely too short for my tastes. I got a DC Dalgliesh on clearance that was 25" or so in length. It is a little wide in the waist and I will probably need to move the strap at some point. The length is actually a good starting point. I would say that I should stick with 25" - 26" length.

The seat was a couple of inches more than what I though that I needed. I have used that seat 43" for my other kilts. I like the loose fit.

I like a tight traditional fit in the waist where the kilt sits just below the rib cage.