My first real wool kilt was a Scotweb casual kilt. The price is certainly attractive. Not wanting to wear it low-waisted (like jeans), I gave them measurements so that it would fall to my knee when worn at my actual waist (just below the ribs).

Pros: quality tartan material (I got a lightweight 11 oz. fabric, since I was in Florida at the time and trying to be thrifty), sturdy (but not fancy) hardware, nicely pleated to the sett. Less fabric and lightweight tartan means it is wonderfully cool to wear in the summer or tropical climates.

Cons: no stabilizer/support material in the waistband. So the tartan itself is taking all the pressure of holding the kilt up when I strap it on. Over the years, this has led to a little stretching, so that a very careful eye an see a little distortion of the tartan around my waist area. Less fabric = less swish when I move, although no one has ever noticed or commented on that. I will say that when I got my first 8-yard kilt, the look was different and much more dressy than my 5-yarder.

I still wear this kilt regularly in the hotter months of the year. I've been using it regularly for over a decade, so it's held up quite well, especially considering the very reasonable price.

I hope this info is helpful to you.

Andrew