Quote Originally Posted by Nanook View Post

Here the coat is not stressed and buttoned but its clearly a tad large and the sleeves are way too long (in that pose the sleeves should be just short of the wrist bone and a bit of shirt (and cuff links) should show.


Degge and Skinner (who represent Kinloch Anderson in London), by contrast, get it even right on a showroom dummy:
I'd say the first photo above is just fine. Perhaps it could be a bit more fitted but for the average person who's wait may fluctuate over the life of a jacket this fitting is a reasonable look and still very sharp. Everything tied together looks very nice.

I may be misunderstanding the point on the last jacket but it does not seem tailored for kilt wear at all. Not personally my taste.