[QUOTE=Beuth Sim;341444] Do I consider it a kilt? No. It is a kilt like garment, in my opinion. QUOTE]

To those who feel this way, a question: what exactly makes this NOT a kilt? The pockets and other trappings? The non-woolen fabric? If that's the case, then in your mind Utilikilts, Freedom Kilts, Union Kilts, NeoKilts, etc. etc., are all just "kilt-like garments?"

That's fine with me (my kilts are tartan wool traditional types), I'm just seeking to understand folks' thinking on this, not to prolong the silly "what is really a kilt" debate....