I own 2 Stillwater kilts, two Scottish made casuals, one Matt Newsome Tank and one USA semi-traditional. Of course, the tank is my favorite. If you go with Stillwater, my recommendation is the Heavyweight, followed by the Standard. However, overall, I'd recommend the USA casual. Sure, it isn't a "tank", but it is a custom, "made to your measurements" kilt. It isn't wool, bur PV is a really good material for every day wear. It is even washable if you follow the instructions. And, Rocky is really a great guy to work with. The only downside is that it will take some time for your kilt to be made. If you want fast service, with good quality, but in a mass made kilt, go with Jerry at Stillwater.