Kilt vs. Tartan?

[emolas]

It's all about the kilt for me, tartan is just a colored design. Granted, I like the designs and colors out there but, like Mr. MacDougall, if I had tartan trews they would not get worn simply because they are not as comfortable as a kilt.

[macwilkin]

It's all about the kilt for me, tartan is just a colored design. Granted, I like the designs and colors out there but, like Mr. MacDougall, if I had tartan trews they would not get worn simply because they are not as comfortable as a kilt.

How do you know that? Do you own a pair of trews?

One of my best friends wears trews on a regular basis to Scottish functions, and loves them.

Regards,

Todd

[emolas]

How do you know that? Do you own a pair of trews?

One of my best friends wears trews on a regular basis to Scottish functions, and loves them.

Regards,

Todd

While I don't actually know that trews aren't as comfortable as a kilt, I can't imagine that any form of trousers would be. That being said, I do like the look of them and might consider wearing them somewhere that trousers were mandated. However, given a choice between bifurcation and freedom, the kilt wins every time whether it be tartan or solid colored. (though I do prefer tartan kilts over solid kilts)

[McG]

A believe as a scot that tartan is maest important, as family tartans derived fae Scotland and therefore i wear mine as an identity tae ma family i wid never wear a plain kilt as i associate them wi Ireland.

[macwilkin]

While I don't actually know that trews aren't as comfortable as a kilt, I can't imagine that any form of trousers would be. That being said, I do like the look of them and might consider wearing them somewhere that trousers were mandated. However, given a choice between bifurcation and freedom, the kilt wins every time whether it be tartan or solid colored. (though I do prefer tartan kilts over solid kilts)

For me, it's all about the tartan. I have no objection to solid colour kilts, such as a saffron or green kilt for Irish heritage, or a tweed kilt a la the Balmoral ghillies -- but when push comes to shove, I wear a kilt as a symbol of my heritage, not necessarily for "freedom". Modern kilts -- well, they're just not my thing, though I don't begrudge anyone wearing them.

I'll be quite honest: I like trousers -- trews, cords, plus fours, etc. I'm not ashamed of it. I know it's not a popular opinion around here, but I'm not going to hide it. There are sometimes I just don't want to wear a kilt, and trews would be a nice alternative on those occasions. A country gent's shooting attire complete with hose and plus fours -- that's a great look. Take a look at what the gents are wearing in The Quiet Man, or Hector's outfits in Monarch of the Glen -- that's what I like.

But again, that's just me. I wouldn't dare force it on anyone else. Just don't knock trews until you've tried them.

Cheers,

Todd

[Barclay]

For me, it's all about the tartan. I have no objection to solid colour kilts, such as a saffron or green kilt for Irish heritage, or a tweed kilt a la the Balmoral ghillies -- but when push comes to shove, I wear a kilt as a symbol of my heritage, not necessarily for "freedom". Modern kilts -- well, they're just not my thing, though I don't begrudge anyone wearing them.

As expected, on the subject of traditionalism, Todd pretty much nails my feelings too. I'm in it for the tartan. I have no objection to non-traditional or modern kilts, and I own a Buzz Kidder OD canvas, I just don't care for them on me.

I like pants too - I have a couple of suits that I honestly look forward to wearing, and a pair of LL Bean chinos that are more comfortable than any kilt I've ever owned!

So, yeah. For me also, it's all about the tartan.



And Todd, I think that, at least concerning Barclay Dress, you know my feelings on trews: No. Just no...on my body, anyway.

[macwilkin]

As expected, on the subject of traditionalism, Todd pretty much nails my feelings too. I'm in it for the tartan. I have no objection to non-traditional or modern kilts, and I own a Buzz Kidder OD canvas, I just don't care for them on me.

I like pants too - I have a couple of suits that I honestly look forward to wearing, and a pair of LL Bean chinos that are more comfortable than any kilt I've ever owned!

So, yeah. For me also, it's all about the tartan.



And Todd, I think that, at least concerning Barclay Dress, you know my feelings on trews: No. Just no...on my body, anyway.

Yeah, after seeing Ralph Barclay's trews in person...

LL Bean Chinos are great -- they are my "work uniform". I'm an "L.L. Bean junkie", to paraphrase the late Jean Shepherd in "A Christmas Story".

T.

[Nick the DSM]

i like the look of tartan/plaid better than solid though i do have a solid black kilt for dress purposes and i mean for dress purposes. if i wear to wear a tux jacket, the kilt would match perfectly and the fabric is almost the same.

[Chef]

For me, it's all about the tartan. I have no objection to solid colour kilts, such as a saffron or green kilt for Irish heritage, or a tweed kilt a la the Balmoral ghillies -- but when push comes to shove, I wear a kilt as a symbol of my heritage, not necessarily for "freedom". Modern kilts -- well, they're just not my thing, though I don't begrudge anyone wearing them.

I'll be quite honest: I like trousers -- trews, cords, plus fours, etc. I'm not ashamed of it. I know it's not a popular opinion around here, but I'm not going to hide it. There are sometimes I just don't want to wear a kilt, and trews would be a nice alternative on those occasions. A country gent's shooting attire complete with hose and plus fours -- that's a great look. Take a look at what the gents are wearing in The Quiet Man, or Hector's outfits in Monarch of the Glen -- that's what I like.

But again, that's just me. I wouldn't dare force it on anyone else. Just don't knock trews until you've tried them.

I think Todd has put it quite well. For me the kilt represents the fact that I am Scottish. I am proud of it and I make a good part of my living from it. I do think that the kilt and tartan go together, one is not quite the same without the other.

For me kilts are just some of the choices in my closet. I could go kilted all the time, but I don't for two reasons: first I happen to have other clothes I like and second a kilt just isn't the most sensible garment for every situation. Again other than in the kitchen, I wear a kilt more than anything else, but by no means exclusively.



By the way, I do own a pair of trews and they are fine, funny thing I think I get more looks in trews with a kilt jacket etc, than I do in a kilt.

[Sir Robert]

For me kilts are plaid but some nice solids beat the heck out of ugly tartans.

Trews no way in hell, at all no, just no!