I received my Burnett-Struth Macdonnell 16 oz Lochcarron 4-5 yd. kilt before Christmas and I am very delighted with it. It is machine stitched with all pleating and detail done on site in the most excellent manner. I was measured at their store and the kilt fit perfectly. Wore it on Christmas eve and day. My preference is for the 4-5 yd kilt but each too their own needs.
At $200 I doubt if the value could be replicated. There is a limited number of tartans however.

I also have a USA Kilt in the MacDonald casual. I added a right side kilt strap and buckle as a feature and it looks great also.