To stripe or sett?

[kiltimabar]

You're right about the lack of strictness or military requirement. My comment was too limited. What is required by EUSPBA is "Highland dress." The ideal is for a pipe band to be "uniform" in dress, if not IN uniform. Still, a good many pipe bands aim for as military a look as they can attain - ghillie brogues rather than plain black shoes; piper shirts, instead of plain white; matching tartans; matching pleating, etc... If you have two Grade 1 bands competing, sometimes their dress code may be the deciding factor.

I was unaware that "ghillie brogues rather than plain black shoes" was a military style--I should think rather the opposite.

[BoldHighlander]

I was unaware that "ghillie brogues rather than plain black shoes" was a military style--I should think rather the opposite.

I think your correct. Was just looking at a picture (circa 1996) of the Highlanders (Seaforths, Gordons and Camerons) on parade and they are all wearing plain black shoes.

I also recall corresponding with a gent a number of years ago who sold surplus UK army wear about shoes, and he had some worn by the Scottish units (that he got direct from them) and they were all plain black shoes as well (no ghillies).

[Jack Daw]

I was unaware that "ghillie brogues rather than plain black shoes" was a military style--I should think rather the opposite.

You are correct; I miswrote...AGAIN! I actually have a pair of patent leather military "parade" shoes that I wear with my spats. But, the pipe bands in the heat of Texas will wear the ghillie brogues.