As a fan of the black shirts and coloured ties, I think you look just fine. I respect and appreciate the guidelines of Highland attire, but I also enjoy adding my own twists. I am not trying to wear a $50 with a home made jacket and pass it off at a Burns night. I like the charcaol tweed argyle and traditional worsted wool kilts I own and wear, so I am not to concerned about adding a newer, hipper twist with the black dress shirt and tie.

Looks good as is Chase. Very sharp and very well pulled together.