Need your opinions

**Jack Daw** · 8th January 09, 10:07 AM

I'm not a fan of the Jacobite shirt, so I have to pass on anything that would go with it.

**LindyLoo** · 8th January 09, 10:42 AM

Well I'm a knitter and I think this is a good idea!
Bet you'd sell MILLIONS over here, it's freezing!

**piper's babe** · 11th January 09, 08:18 PM

I gotta tell ya, the model is hot!

**Squeaky McMurdo** · 11th January 09, 08:33 PM

Originally Posted by Deil the Yin

Man... yall are on crack, and not the good kind!?

That outfit is cool as hell! Of course if you don't go for the Renfaire look, no you're not gonna buy it.

Anywho... guid on ye, McHummel! And pish-posh on the descenters, I say... :P

PS: An' if Arlen would wear it, ye know its cuil! I mean, did yall see his wedding kit? Kick ****, dude.

I actually really like this too, but I also think the knit would look better if it was tighter. You know what would be really cool? To knit the vest to match the knit of the kilt hose....

But I would buy this as is for my husband if given the chance. I say kudos to you for the idea! (says the lass that is a sucker for ghillie shirts)

--Chelsea McMurdo--

P.S. The best kilt advice will always come from the ladies in your life. When in doubt ask them.

**Nighthawk** · 11th January 09, 09:45 PM

Originally Posted by Squeaky McMurdo

I actually really like this too, but I also think the knit would look better if it was tighter. You know what would be really cool? To knit the vest to match the knit of the kilt hose....

But I would buy this as is for my husband if given the chance. I say kudos to you for the idea! (says the lass that is a sucker for ghillie shirts)

--Chelsea McMurdo--

P.S. The best kilt advice will always come from the ladies in your life. When in doubt ask them.

Here here! I like you.

**Nighthawk** · 11th January 09, 09:48 PM

Originally Posted by BroosterB1

Of course you do Hawk, if you beg and plead hard enough she might sell you the prototype!

I like the look, just need a tighter knit.

Yeah, that wouldn't do me a bit of good. I'm slightly larger than you, so there's no way I would fit into that. Thanks for the compliment though!

**Thebigeman77** · 12th January 09, 12:19 AM

I really like that, I'd certainly wear one, even with a T-shirt.

**Mipi** · 12th January 09, 01:18 AM

Reading this thread, I can only say that I agree with most of posted comments.

Yes it looks nice and yes I see it more like a costume. And this is the only reason I wouldn’t wear it, while I see the kilt as an ordinary (every day) garment, and as a costume only on special occasions.

On the other hand; it’s your garment and if you like it, no one should try to stop you!!!!!!!!!!!

**Cerebite** · 12th January 09, 07:50 AM

Originally Posted by Thebigeman77

I really like that, I'd certainly wear one, even with a T-shirt.

Just like Onslow in the middle of the back row

**Carolina Kiltman** · 12th January 09, 11:19 AM

Originally Posted by LewisG

It looks too much like a costume for me. I would rarely wear a ghillie shirt: just at highland games when it isn't very hot. However the overall design goes well with the ghillie shirt. I agree with the others that the knit is too open.

I agree that it is a little "off"", but the idea is basically good. I would tighten up the knitting, (like the idea of matching the kilt hose).

With my history of skin cancer I will wear the gillie shirt when it is hot! It keeps the sun off me, and provides a layer of (relatively) cool air against my skin.