I think it's a great look! in 18th century kilting, there is no kilt pin, so I"ve never worn one until the last year when I started to put together a modern kilt kit (thanks to X Marks the Scot getting me interested in it). I only have one pin I use, actually picked it up at a yard sale.....it's a sceptor with a crown at the top, although I have other pins, etc. I could wear. I really like the idea of the pin or broach up higher on the kilt. And Robert!!! THANKS for the fashion show.....WOW, great outfits!
And, I'll probably show my ignorance here. Who is Henry in the photo?

Malcolm MacWm., 42nd RHR GrenCoy, ASM British Brigade