Denied

[macwilkin]

With respect, I tend to disagree. As I stated, unless I am a member of the wedding party where a particular type of dress is required during the ceremony, my duty 'as a gentleman' , or should I say 'kilt wearing gentleman' after the ceremony or as a guest is to dress appropriately for the time, venue and type of event. In my case this dress will include a kilt, as I actually no longer own a "saxon" suit (one that fits anyway), and anyone I know won't be surprised to see it.

I think this belief among kilt wearing folks that wearing one's kilt to a wedding, at least one where the groom and his attendants not also kilted, will somehow draw too much attention away from the bride and groom, means that one might still view the kilt as a eccentric costume rather than acceptable mens clothing.

No disagreements there, Zardoz.

Todd

[Zardoz]

Wow, while I am composing my post in my slow two fingered style, Panache comes along and sums it all up for us! Thanks Jamie

[LewisG]

To me the day is for the bride and groom. As a guest, I would not want to wear anything that would distract from the bride and groom or make me the center of attention. The fact that others may dress inappropriately is irrelevant. My wife and I went to a Valentine party. I asked my wife if I should wear a kilt. Her reply was only if you want to make a statement. I went in pants and a red sweater, just like almost everyone else.

[Panache]

Zardoz,

Don't worry we all know that some clothes just shrink over time. I blame moths.

Cheers

Jamie

[Bart_In_A_Kilt]

Always remember you gotta make sure the brides O.K. with it. It's her big day afterall. [snip].

Words to live by.

[be da veva]

I asked if it would be alright, they told me they had no problem with it. I asked again to make sure, they said to go ahead. I was kilted and they were pi***d off... Still are after 4 years... You should of heard them when I got married... oh the things they would do.... I didn`t care and they didn`t do anything...

Even when you ask if it`s ok, it might not be...
In these situation, I say i`m sorry and try to keep a low profile... (which is impossible when kilted...) ;o)

[pastorsteve]

The point is, he's one of the groomsmen. He is in the wedding party and therefore needs to wear a tux, if that is the dress of the day. When and if (depending on this particular wedding) the bride, groom and wedding party change into something less formal, he too can choose his attire. Otherwise, tux is the preferred dress for the wedding party - if I read the bride's wishes correctly.

[MacMillan of Rathdown]

Personally, I don't care for the modern habit of trying to make everyone lok like they're in livery or something by dressing everyone alike. It smacks of trying to imitate what the royals or "rich folk" wear.

It has nothing to do with imitating royalty or the "rich folks". Rather, it has to do with having a sense of "occasion". I have, as a guest, attended ultra-formal white tie weddings at 7 o'clock in the evening, and extremely informal weddings on the beach at 11 o'clock in the morning. Both weddings had their own sense of occasion, and those attending were quite comfortable to be there and to share the moment with the happy couple-- while complying with of the mode of dress requested on the invitation.

Something that seems to be often overlooked on this forum is that when one is invited to a wedding-- or any other function-- attendance is not mandatory. Rather than contacting the host and requesting dispensation to dress outside the norm, one has the option to RSVP their regrets.

When you receive an invitation you have three options: Politely decline; dress as you please, which shows a colossal lack of respect for the host and other guests; conform to the requested dress code.

As far as "checking with the bride" is concerned, technically she isn't the host-- the hosts are her parents, who are paying for the wedding. They issue the invitations and they (obviously in consultation with the bride) set the dress code. Calling the bride, or her parents, to ask if you can wear your kilt borders on boorish behaviour. Your request will be met with one of two answers:

(1) "No, I'm sorry, but this really is a formal wedding, and we'd appreciate it if you would respect our daughter's wishes."

(2) "Well, it is a formal wedding, but by all means do wear your kilt if that will make you feel more comfortable. Really, your presence is so important that our daughter wouldn't care if you came dressed as a Whirling Dervish. Really, she wouldn't."

Did I say asking to wear the kilt bordered on boorish behaviour? I was wrong, it crosses the line. A request of this nature is totally self serving, and places the host (or the bride) in the position of having to choose between being dishonest, or being rude. A gentleman would never put his host in such a socially awkward position.

If you are invited to a wedding outside of Scotland, unless you are part of the kilted wedding party, your best course of action is to dress as all of the other gentlemen are dressed. If you don't want to do that, then good manners would require you to politely decline the invitation and send the wedding gift to the home of the bride's parents.

[CDNSushi]

Really, your presence is so important that our daughter wouldn't care if you came dressed as a Whirling Dervish. Really, she wouldn't."

Hmmmm. You COULD be onto something here...

[SteveB]

Weddings today take on many different "styles". I have been invited to be part of a wedding party, in a tux, kilted, both PC and shirtsleeve, in shorts and sandals (island beach wedding). To each I have been kitted as expected for the event. In every occasion, the intent is to honour the bride. I have been to three weddings in Scotland, one kilted (My family) and two in tuxes. In Canada all three weddings were kilted. In Germany, I was kilted. In the U.S. every variety that is possible. Each and every occasion was memorable for the newly joined couple in a positive way.
I enjoy being in my kilt, but it is not the only possible attire for me.
Slainte