How long should your tie be worn with a kilt?

[McMurdo]

Even this would be too long for me. I don't like it when ties look too long. You see it all the time when guy wear pants hanging off the hips, and it looks sloppy. The kilt is worn higher, so it makes me want to wear ties shorter. The problem is my new university tie is really long. I guess for the change in the fashion of pants.

I find that on a daily basis the tie ends up in a different position it is simply a function of tying a tie, this would then denote some leeway in the length of said tie, longer than in my photo would I think look sloppy, however I do not think that the length achieved is sloppy at all. To my eye it looks far better than a tie that is entirely too short.

[The Guy in the Kilt at UC]

I find that on a daily basis the tie ends up in a different position it is simply a function of tying a tie, this would then denote some leeway in the length of said tie, longer than in my photo would I think look sloppy, however I do not think that the length achieved is sloppy at all. To my eye it looks far better than a tie that is entirely too short.

I did not intend to mean that I thought you looked sloppy. I really only meant that about ties and low riding pants.