You know, it's not at all traditional, but I like it. I'm also a fan of 5 button waistcoats with a PC. To my eye it just looks better. (I've never been a fan of too much shirt showing.)
But I think this is one of those garments where we say 'To each his own.'

Maclowlife... your Red PC will be no match for the Regency inspired Kilt outfit I am working on.

It will combine a jacket like this:





And a vest like this:



And I will be sooooo dapper.