Well, here goes the show of my ignorance: I didn't know there were "full" brogues that were different from ghillies.

I have a few pair of other dress shoes in black, but none of them would really look right with a kilt. They're mostly very contemporary styles that I just don't think would match well.

But in answer to your question - no, I'm not dead set on *anything* in particular, just what would look best for more semi-/formal occasions; I honestly thought that ghillie brogues were the only things that were really acceptable for more black tie affairs...