I'd got with No1. (in your post) They are British MoD issue and a good quality shoe, I've worn them meeself.

Failing that, I've got two pairs of these:



One in Black and one in Brown. Proper sturdy footwear. I take a UK 10 or 10.5 and I bought 10's from these chaps and the shoes fit well. They are not extravagantly expensive either, if you are looking for a good quality shoe to wear on your special day but not every day, why do you want to spend over £100

Search ebay-UK for a shop called "britishshoes". They charge 20 quid on top, for postage to Japan. There are also other styles available on their ebay site including these in Black.

Review of these brogues here