Sorry for the repeat a post but this was addressed to Xman. A good member.

To say what you did say would indicate to me that you did not take the time to type your answer to an honest question. You have the right to think this but I surprised you say it in print. Sorry but I do not agree with your statement.
I answer with your own saying.

"He was a dreamer, a thinker, a speculative philosopher ... or, as his wife would have it, an idiot."

I assume you were having a wee Dram and would hope you did NOT think out your answer.
A wee dram is always good to show the true man...

Kindest regards
Seven oaks.