But the problem is, as mentioned, with enforcement. This idea that no rules will be enforced unless a member complains will naturally lead to only selective enforcement. One poster can freely discuss his weapon project while another will be quickly shut down, and it depends solely on whether some anonymous complainant decides to report it. This seems patently unfair to those who wish to discuss their kilt-related items. They cannot know whether they'll be mod-slapped or not, since it's the membership (and not the mods) who initiates the process.
Well put, Tobus.

With a diverse membership, it's only natural that some members are much more sensitive to this issue than others. To those who are, may I remind you that a post is just like one channel on the TV—there are hundreds of others out there and you can switch to another one (post) with a click of your mouse. Perhaps we should have post warnings, "WARNING: The following post contains information on an itsiy bitsy knife you stick in your sock." Just kidding.

Personally, I find a well crafted edged weapon/tool fascinating. I feel the same way about many firearms, but I do not wish to impose my preference on others, nor do I appreciate others with the opposite view imposing their ethical/moral stance on me. That said, there are other outlets for such discussions outside of XMTS, and I accept that.

Where firearms and history meet and are related to the kilt (highland regiments, historical events, reenactments, etc.) I think it's part and parcel of Scottish/kilted heritage and makes for most interesting discussions. I fail to see it's relevance to the modern debate over firearm ownership or use. What was, was.

I feel the same way about edged creations by many of the do-it-yourselfers who have posted here. They are to be congratulated on their craftsmanship and creativity. And, yes, these sgian dubhs and dirks are an important part of the heritage associated with the kilt.

Deep breath. . .There, I feel better.

Now, about some of those hideous sporrans that were posted a couple of months ago, MODERATORS, there ought to be a rule.