"LONG JOHNS" with a KILT ????

[McMurdo]

Ahh, but here is the rub (& has been discussed else where before) what is "proper"?
With under wear or without?
That really is what we are talking about here (at least I am ) & I am *NOT* advocating long johns under the kilt (see my earlier post -- #9 -- on this thread).

I agree that neither one is saying that he should be wearing long johns under his kilt, I just really have a problem with "Giving the newbie a break" when what he is doing is so obviously incorrect. To my mind "At least he's making an effort" is akin to "He doesn't really know what he's doing"